Want to recommend an eyeliner from Oriflame which I think is great!
A while ago I reviewed their gel eyeliner, and now it is a liquid dip eyeliner I have tried :) Giordani Gold Liquid Eye Liner it is called and costs SEK 150.
When it comes to eyeliner, it's a matter of taste what you like to work with, there are very many variants, for example: gel eyeliner, cake eyeliner, dip eyeliner, a felt-tip pen-like eyeliner.
A dip eyeliner is a liquid eyeliner as the brush is included in the cap on the package. You just unscrew the cap and start painting with the brush.
The first thing I reacted to was that I like the brush very much, the tip is very narrow if you want a thin line, and if you press a little more it will be wider.
On the eyes it sat just fine all day, no smudges and I can probably say that it is rub-proof. When I have painted lines on my hand, however, it disappears if I scratch with my nail. But you never have such a big strain on your eyes :)
So I give this eyeliner a thumbs up, good brush, easy to work with, the color turns carbon black and it fits well along the lash line all day!
Any of you who tested? :)
English 
Swedish 
Spanish